How gravity changes a classic 9x9 number puzzle
See how a gravity 9x9 number puzzle drops clues to the bottom of each column, and how solvers count stacks to rebuild the original grid.
Imagine a 9×9 grid whose top row holds a single clue, a 7 in the fourth column, with no other numbers above it. In a standard puzzle of this size, each row, column and three-by-three box holds the numbers 1 to 9 exactly once, and solvers fill the grid by ruling out numbers already present in the same row, column or box.
In the variant on the Logic Masters Deutschland puzzle portal, the gravity rule moves the 7 away from the position where it was printed. The clues of a normal puzzle drop straight down and exit the bottom of grid. Each clue keeps its orientation, passes through no other clue, and never lands on the same cell as another. On the finished page, the numbers sit at the bottom of their columns, and in this example the 7 is about to leave through the lower edge.
What falling clues do to the grid
A solver who starts with a gravity page, such as the 2023 puzzle on the German Logic Masters portal, first finds where each clue currently sits within its column. All clues fall straight down, so every printed number stays in the column where it started. A clue that started in column four is still in column four, only lower. The page gives no sign of the row a clue was moved from, so solvers must work that row out as part of the solution.
Solvers check the no-overlap rule next. No two clues occupy the same cell, and the clues in a single column appear in their original order, since none of them passed over another. Solvers read each column from the bottom upward and count the clues stacked in it. A column with three printed numbers held three clues originally, and the lowest printed number stands for the lowest original clue.
Rows and boxes call for a different kind of reading. Printed positions no longer match the original ones, so solvers do not apply the usual row and box checks to the printed page. Solvers deal with the column count and the stacking order first.
How solving steps change under gravity
In this version, the number in a cage's corner is the sum of the digits within that cage's gravitational effect zone. The digit placed in the cage sets how far the zone reaches, and distance is measured in orthogonal moves: steps up, down, left or right. Diagonal steps do not count.
Solvers of this puzzle begin by finding the cells that a particular digit can reach. A cage holding the digit 2 covers cells fewer steps away than a cage holding the digit 6, so the reach zone changes each time a solver tries a different digit. Solvers then use the sum at the corner to check cells both inside and outside the cage.
GravitySometimesFalls, a 2024 puzzle on the same portal, applies gravity to the dots between cells. When a dot joins two vertically paired cells, the larger number has to sit below the smaller one. One solver commented that the puzzle could be solved without the gravity rule, so the dots alone may have been enough for some solvers.
NumFall drops numbers to the lowest empty cell, so drop order is the puzzle, and the game is on the App Store.
Practice a gravity variant on paper
The beginner guide for variant puzzles from Logic Masters uses small teaching boards of 4 × 4 or 6 × 6, with digits 1 to 4 or 1 to 6. A 4 × 4 board from that guide is sufficient for a first attempt on paper.
- Copy the board onto graph paper, including every printed clue, and make a second copy to work on.
- Pick a column. Each clue in that column moves straight down in its original order, and no two clues may end up in the same square.
- Write the new column layout in pencil so that the original remains visible on the first copy.
- Look at the rows in order from the top row to the bottom row, then examine the columns from the leftmost to the rightmost column, and finally inspect the four 2×2 boxes. Repeating this same sequence each time helps you spot a repeated digit more quickly.
If a clue in the chosen column has no other clues beneath it, it moves to the bottom cell. When there's two clues stacked, the one lower down settles into the bottom cell, while the one higher up sits immediately above it.
Before looking at a row, a solver can draw a straight line from a clue's starting spot to the spot where it lands. The line shows every square the clue crosses and tells the solver which row the clue ends up in.
FAQ
What is a gravity 9x9 number puzzle?
Players get a sheet where the clues from a normal 9×9 puzzle have simply fallen straight down and exited the bottom of the grid. The numbers keep the same orientation, they pass through no other clues, and they never overlap. This was described on a Logic Masters Deutschland puzzle page from 2023.
How do you solve a gravity number puzzle?
Solvers normally begin by counting the clues that are stacked in each column. Because each clue remains in the column it started in, the row from which each clue came must then be determined by looking at the order in which the clues are stacked.
Do the normal row and box rules still apply in a gravity puzzle?
Because the printed puzzle's positions are different than the original, the usual row and box checks are not used on the printed page. Those checks belong to the original 9×9 grid that solvers rebuild piece by piece.
Where did the classic 9x9 number puzzle come from?
The game appeared in a US puzzle magazine in May 1979. The author was later discovered to be Howard Garns, a retired architect.
Can beginners practice gravity puzzles on a small grid?
A 4×4 board that uses the digits 1 to 4 is good for a first attempt, and Logic Masters' beginner guide to variant puzzles suggests using that size. Many players copy board onto graph paper and shift the clues one column at a time.