Move order in falling number puzzles and why it matters
Move order in falling number puzzles decides which cells stay open. See how one drop blocks later numbers, with a 4x4 example and a short routine to try.
Imagine a 4×4 board with a single empty column, where the tray still holds two numbers. A 3 is one of the two numbers in the tray. Which of two cells the 3 fills depends on the column the solver clicks. Once the solver selects a column, the number falls on its own to the lowest empty cell there, which means the landing row is already set.
The standard rule also holds, so each row, column and box must contain every number exactly once. When a 3 lands in the bottom row, it may be right for that spot, or it may sit in the same row or box as another 3 the solver has yet to place. Solvers who study the whole board before tapping often find that the cell they wanted is still higher up the column.
Each drop lands in the lowest open cell, and that changes which cell is lowest when the next number falls. Which cells stay open is decided by the order of the drops.
Drops lock cells for every later move
Two things happen together when solvers watch a single drop closely. The number takes the lowest empty cell in the tapped column, and from then on it cannot go in any other cell of the same row, column or box. A 2 placed in the third row of a 4x4 board, for example, can no longer go anywhere else in that row, anywhere else in that column, or in the other cells of its 2x2 box.
Dropping a number too early can leave a different number without any legal cell. For example, a 3 might fall into a cell that another 3 needed, or into a spot that makes the remaining 3 conflict with its row. A number remains in the tray, yet every open cell where it could go is blocked. Solvers often see the problem only after the drop, once the tray number has no place to go.
This happens on the Quick 4x4 board with 30 levels, where few cells leave little room for error, and on the Classic 6x6 board with 100 levels, where longer chains of blocked cells are harder to see ahead of time. NumFall on the App Store is built around this, since the drop order is the core of the game.
Testing two drop orders on a 4x4 board
The imagined 4×4 board has a 3 and a 2 in the tray. Only column two still has room, and every other column is full. Column two has two empty spots, one in row three and one in row four. Rows are numbered from the top, so row four is at the bottom.
In the first sequence, the solver puts the 3 into column two. The 3 drops to the lowest empty spot, which is row four. Looking at row four next, the solver sees that the only spot left for a 2 was that same position, which the 3 now fills. Since the 2 has no valid place in that row, the board cannot be completed from there.
In the second step the solver places the number 2 first. It drops the 2 into the lowest empty cell of column two, which is row four, and this satisfies the requirement for row four. The solver then examines row three, and finds that the number 3 can still be put in column two, in the cell just above the 2.
The solver also examines the other empty cell where a 3 might fit, which is in column four. It sees that the rules for the row and the box also allow a 3 in that place. Thus, the number 3 remains possible in two different spots in this example, and the solver can decide which one to use after reviewing the rest of row three.
Practice drop order before dropping
Solvers who follow a brief routine usually take the same three steps before each move. First, they examine board and list the empty cells for each number, noting only the row and column of each cell. Second, they cross out any cell where the number would duplicate an entry in its row, column, or box. Third, they select the move that keeps the most empty cells available for the remaining numbers.
Levels in a set of ten are timed. Finishing quickly and without errors gives three stars. A routine that takes longer than the errors it avoids wastes time, so solvers usually restrict the list to the numbers still in the tray and to the lowest empty cell of each column.
Practice is easiest on small boards. The 4x4 guide on the NumFall home page gives boards where each list holds only a few cells. The 9x9 logic grid guide offers longer lists, which show how quickly the open cells multiply when many numbers remain.
Before each drop, examine the empty cells in that column to see which ones could still take the number.
FAQ
Does the order you drop numbers matter in a falling number puzzle?
Because each number goes into the lowest empty spot of the column that is tapped, the order in which the numbers are placed changes which cells remain open for the remaining numbers in the tray. Dropping a number too early may leave another number with no legal cell.
Can you choose which row a number lands in?
Solvers choose only the column, not the row. Each number lands in the lowest empty cell of the chosen column, so the row depends on what already fills the cells below.
What happens if a number has nowhere to go?
The board cannot be finished from that position, since a number is still in the tray and every cell that could take it is blocked. Most solvers see this only after they have dropped the number.
How do you decide which number to drop first?
Solvers usually note the empty cells that could hold each tray number. They then eliminate cells where that number would duplicate in the same row, column, or box. As a last step, they pick the placement that keeps the most options open for the numbers still to come.
Which board size is easiest for practicing drop order?
A 4×4 board is easiest because each row and column contains only a few empty squares. A 9×9 grid has longer lists, so solvers see how quickly the empty squares multiply.