NumFall

Scanning technique for number grid puzzles, step by step

Learn a scanning technique for number grid puzzles: pick the unit with the fewest gaps, note what it needs, place numbers, and scan again on 4x4 and 9x9

Eleven cells of a 4x4 grid are filled in, and five cells are still empty. Many beginners try a number in one empty cell and then another number two rows away, with no set order to the cells they look at. Solvers who scan work differently. A solver picks one row, column or box, checks which numbers it already holds, and works out which numbers it still needs. A row on a 4x4 board that has three numbers placed needs just one more, so its empty cell can take only one answer.

In 1979 Howard Garns created the 9x9 grid with 3x3 boxes for a US puzzle magazine, and the same check works on that board. Since every row, column and box holds each number once, the method stays the same whatever the size of the grid.

Pick one unit and scan it fully

Careful solvers begin by counting the empty squares in every row, column and box, and then pick the unit with the fewest. The 4×4 example has five empty squares spread over several units, and one of its rows has only one empty square. Solvers start with that row, since it needs the least work.

With a selected row of 2, 4, blank, 1, the solver first notes the numbers already in that unit: 1, 2 and 4. Because the 4×4 board uses the digits 1 to 4, the number missing from the row is 3. The row lacks only one number, and any other digit placed in the empty square would repeat one already there.

The solver looks at the column and the 3×3 box containing the empty cell before writing a 3. When the column or the box already has a 3, the puzzle holds a mistake, and the solver has to go back and find it. When neither the column nor the box has a 3, the row and the other two units all support the placement.

The steps are the same each time:

  • Solvers count the empty cells in each group and choose the group with the fewest blanks.
  • Write down the numbers that the unit already contains.
  • Name the numbers it is missing.
  • Before putting a number in a cell, check the cell's column and its box for any conflicts.

Record what each scan rules out

When a unit has more than one gap, solvers write small candidate numbers in each empty cell. Solvers keep these pencil notes in a corner of the cell, so the notes stay apart from a placed number. The solver scans a row and writes down only the numbers that the row still needs. Next the solver scans a column and removes every candidate that the column already holds.

Where a number is missing from both a row and a column, it can go only in the cells that both lines allow. When the row has two empty cells and the column passes through only one of them, the solver marks the crossing cell as the spot where the number may go. The row's other empty cell no longer has that candidate.

Take a 3×3 box that needs the numbers 1, 2 and 3 yet has just two empty cells. The box must already contain one of those numbers, or the puzzle is wrong. A solver looking at a box with two blanks that need 1 and 2 sees that the first blank sits in a row already containing 1, so that blank can hold only 2. The remaining blank then takes the 1.

The solver never makes a guess. Each hint comes from a number already on the board, and the solver deletes a hint as soon as a new placement makes it invalid.

Run the scan again after each placement

Each number a player places changes what can go in its row, its column and its box at the same time. If you write a 3 in the top row, no other square in that row, that column or that box can contain a 3. Any candidate notes in those cells that list a 3 are removed, and some cells may then have only one candidate left.

After completing a row or column, solvers go back to the same unit or to a unit that now has the fewest empty squares. In the 4×4 example, filling the one missing square in a row leaves four squares still empty. A column that originally had two empty squares may now have only one, so that column becomes the next one to examine. Solvers recalculate the number of empty squares after each new number is placed, not just at the beginning.

The NumFall Quick 4×4 mode has 30 levels where beginners can practice this kind of scan.

In the next puzzle the solver examines the area that has the fewest empty squares, places whatever numbers are forced there and then proceeds to the area that now has the fewest gaps.

  • scanning technique
  • number grid puzzles
  • logic puzzles
  • 4x4 grid
  • solving technique

FAQ

How do you scan a number grid puzzle?

Solvers select a row, column or box, typically the one with the fewest blank spots, and write down the numbers it already contains. The numbers that are missing from that group are the only possible entries for its empty cells.

Which row or column should I start with in a number puzzle?

A unit that has only one or two empty spots is usually the first place to play, because it limits the options the most. Counting the blanks in each row, column and box tells you which unit that is.

What are pencil marks in number grid puzzles?

Pencil marks are tiny candidate numbers scribbled in the corner of a blank cell. As soon as a row, column, or box already contains that number, the solver removes the mark.

Does the scanning method work on a 9x9 grid?

Yes, the same rule applies because every row, every column and every box contains each number exactly once, no matter how large the grid is. Howard Garns introduced the 9×9 version that uses 3×3 boxes in 1979.

Why count empty cells again after each number is placed?

Each move alters the possibilities in row, the column, and the box that intersect. A unit that had two empty spaces may then have only one left, so it becomes the next unit to examine.

Share this article

Know a puzzle fan who would like it? Send it their way.

← All articles