NumFall

Naked pairs in number puzzles and how to spot them

Learn how naked pairs in number puzzles work on a 6x6 board: spot two cells with the same two candidates, then cross those numbers out of the rest of the

Four spots are empty in one row of the 6×6 board. That row already holds a 1 and a 4. The numbers 2, 3, 5 and 6 must fill the remaining empty cells, with each number used once.

When a row has four numbers placed already, solvers write down the numbers that could go in each of its four empty cells. Solvers call these possible numbers candidates, and they find them by checking the column and the box that each cell belongs to. The candidates that appear in this row are:

  • Cell A can be 2 or 5.
  • Cell B can be 2 or 5.
  • Cell C: 2, 3, 5 or 6
  • Cell D: 3, 5 or 6

Cells A and B contain exactly the same two candidates and no others. A pair of cells that share two identical candidates in a row, column, or box is called a naked pair. One of those two cells must be a 2 and the other a 5, although the notes have not yet specified which cell has which number.

Spotting a pair in one unit

Solvers who use this method first list all possible numbers in every empty square of a single row, column, or box. Any number already present in the same row, column, or box is crossed out, and the numbers that remain are written in the square. A row with five empty squares gives the solver five short lists to work from before any pairs are looked for.

Once the candidate lists are written, the solver goes through them one line at a time. The solver looks for two cells whose possible numbers are exactly the same two. Suppose one cell in a column can only be 2 or 5, and another cell in the same column can only be 2 or 5 as well: those two cells make a naked pair. One of the two cells must hold the 2 and the other must hold the 5.

Each of the two cells must list exactly two possible numbers. A cell listing 2, 5 and 6 cannot pair with a cell listing 2 and 5, since the first cell might still be a 6 and the 2 and 5 might go in other cells. Two cells that each list 2, 5 and 6 are not a pair either, since three possible numbers remain.

Solvers compare only cells that share the same unit. Two cells in different rows that both show 2 and 5 are not a naked pair.

Removing candidates from the rest of the unit

The cells labeled A and B are the only places in that row that can contain the numbers 2 and 5. Because of that, those two numbers cannot appear in any other cells in the same row. To solve, a player checks every other empty cell in the row and eliminates 2 and 5 from their lists if they are possible there.

In the row above, cell C shows the numbers 2, 3, 5 and 6, and cell D shows 3, 5 and 6. The procedure for cell C is as follows:

  • Read the two numbers in the pair: 2 and 5.
  • Find cell C that contains the numbers 2, 3, 5 and 6.
  • Cross out the 2 and the 5 from cell C.
  • Read what remains: 3 and 6.

Cell D no longer contains a 5. It now holds only 3 and 6. Suppose a third cell listed only 2, 5 and 6: with the 2 and the 5 marked impossible, only a 6 would be left, and the solver could write a 6 in that cell.

Solvers can leave open which of A and B holds the 2. The removal holds either way, since the two cells will take one number each.

On a 9×9 board the rule works in the same way. A box must hold every number once, so a naked pair inside a box lets the solver remove those two numbers from the other empty cells of that box. A naked pair found in a row or in a column eliminates the same two numbers from the other empty cells of that row or column.

Checking the pair before relying on it

A new number placed in a row, column or box can change the possibilities in either cell, so solvers look at the pair again after each placement. Entering a 5 in another cell of the column that crosses cell A means cell A can no longer be 5, and only 2 is left for it. The pair disappears, so the solver writes 2 in cell A. Consequently, cell B must be 5, and the notes in the remaining cells of that row must be updated again.

The rule limits possibilities only within the unit that contains the pair. Because cells A and B are in the same row, the numbers 2 and 5 are eliminated from all the other cells in that row. A cell that is in the same column as A but in a different row keeps the numbers 2 and 5 unless there is a separate pair in that column that changes that. Thus, solvers examine rows, columns and boxes separately, and two cells count as a pair for a unit only if both cells are located in that unit.

When two cells of a pair are in the same box, as can happen in some rows of a 6×6 board that uses 2×3 boxes, the two numbers that go in those cells can be eliminated from the rest of that box. A solver can try this on a printed 6×6 grid by writing the possible candidates in every empty cell of one row and then looking for two cells that show exactly the same two numbers and nothing else.

  • naked pairs
  • candidates
  • logic techniques
  • 6x6 grid
  • 9x9 grid

FAQ

What is a naked pair in number puzzles?

A naked pair means that two cells in the same row, column, or box show exactly the same two possible numbers and no other possibilities. Those two numbers must occupy the pair of cells.

How do you find a naked pair in a row?

The solver writes the candidate numbers into each empty square of the row, then checks the lists. When two squares contain exactly the same two candidates, for example 2 and 5, they are identified as a pair.

What do you do after you find a naked pair?

Solvers remove the two numbers of that pair from every other empty cell in the same row, column, or box. A number can be entered whenever a cell is left with a single possibility after that removal.

Do two cells with 2, 5 and 6 count as a naked pair?

No, each cell still has three options, and the numbers could end up elsewhere. Each of the two cells must be limited to the same two numbers.

Can a naked pair stop being a pair?

Yes, a new number placed in column or box of one cell can remove a candidate. When cell A loses its 5 and is left with only a 2, the solver writes the 2 and checks the notes again.

Share this article

Know a puzzle fan who would like it? Send it their way.

← All articles