Pencil marks in number puzzles: when they help or hinder
Pencil marks in number puzzles can speed up a solve or slow it down. See when candidate notes help, when they go stale, and a short rule for keeping them
Imagine a 4×4 board where the last row has three empty cells. A solver who writes every possible number into each empty cell could end up with a sheet full of small notes before making the first move. Those small notes are called pencil marks. They are the candidate numbers written in the corner of an empty cell to indicate which numbers might still fit there.
Pencil marks have been part of this type of puzzle since the first printed versions. The puzzle that Howard Garns created, known as Number Place, first appeared in May 1979 in the American magazine Dell Pencil Puzzles and Word Games. The puzzle was introduced to Japanese readers in 1984 and was later given a shorter name.
Marks are a tool, not a rule. Some solvers use them on every board, some only when they are stuck, and some never. Each reader chooses when marks are worth the time.
Where candidate notes earn their place
On a 6×6 board, if one row already contains the numbers 1, 3, 4, and 6, there are two empty cells at the ends of that row. That row shows that only the numbers 2 and 5 are missing, so each of those empty cells can contain either 2 or 5 and no other number.
A solver then checks the column above and below the first empty cell. When the column already holds a 5, the cell cannot take a 5, so the solver can write in the 2. When neither number shows in the column, the solver turns to the 2x3 region that contains the cell. A 2 in that region would remove it from the list as well.
Noting two or three possible numbers in the corner of a cell takes little time. Marking a cell with four or five possibilities is usually not worth the effort, since the long list will soon change.
Notes help most when a solver has to compare cells that share a row, column, or region. When two cells in a region can only be 2 or 5, those two numbers must fill those two cells, and no other cell in the region can hold a 2 or a 5. Without written marks, a solver has to rebuild that comparison from the board every time, while marks put both cells side by side on the page.
Notes that go stale after each placement
On a 4×4 board the solver puts a 3 in the bottom row and continues without removing any notes. Earlier, the solver had written a 3 as a candidate in two other cells of that row, one cell in the same column, and one cell in the same 2×2 box. Those four notes now cannot be used for any moves, because each of those cells already shares a row, a column, or a box with a 3.
Each later scan takes more time. A solver who reads a cell and sees a 3 listed has to look at the board again to check that the 3 still fits. A cell that holds only 1 and 4 can look as if it holds 1, 3 and 4, and a pair that would have been easy to spot stays hidden behind a number that should have been erased.
In NumFall, a number falls to the lowest empty space in the column the solver taps. The order of the drops decides which cell each number lands in, and that decides which notes stay correct. A 3 dropped first into one column lands in a different cell than a 3 dropped after another column has been filled. The possible candidates in the neighboring cells change as well when this occurs. A note written before a drop may point to a cell the number never ends up in.
NumFall is free on iPhone and iPad, and since its drop order is the puzzle, solvers check their notes after each drop.
A simple rule for keeping marks short
A workable rule has two parts. Possible numbers go into a cell only once the row, column and box checks are done and only when two or three possibilities remain. A cell that still allows four or five possibilities stays blank till more of the board is filled.
The solver does the same short job after every placement. In the row, column and box of the number just placed, that number is erased from the candidates. Next, the solver looks again at every cell that lost a note. A cell that falls from three numbers to one can be filled right away, and a cell that falls from three to two may now make a pair with a neighboring cell.
A 9×9 board has 81 squares, and a 4×4 board has 16. Notes pile up faster on a 9×9 board, which has many more squares. A note in every empty square can fill a page before any number is placed, and the rule for placing notes matters more on the larger board.
The habit to practice on the next board is simple: place a number, delete it from the same row, column and box, and then recheck the cells that changed.
FAQ
What are pencil marks in number puzzles?
A pencil mark is a small number written in the corner of an empty cell. The mark lists the numbers that could still go in that cell, so the solver does not need to check the whole board again each time.
Should I write pencil marks in every empty cell?
Many solvers only put marks on cells that have two or three candidates left. Cells that have four or five possibilities are normally left blank, because the list of candidates in those cells may change after the next number is placed.
When did number placement puzzles first appear in print?
Howard Garns's puzzle was first published in May 1979 in a US puzzle magazine.
Do pencil marks slow down a solve?
They can do so because older possible numbers remain on the board after a number is placed. Solvers who remove the placed number from the row, column, and box generally find the next scan quickly again.
Is it okay to play without pencil marks?
Some solvers never use these markers. Other solvers turn to them only when a board stalls. The markers are a tool, and each solver chooses if they are worth the effort.